Just wondering what everyone thinks about this. My wife has a commoner that she's training to one day be a necro and she has a mod slice LE that she wanted to train as a primary melee. Personally, I don't have that faith in a LE weapon but wanted to see what everyone else though.
"They have not wanted peace at all; they have wanted to be spared war -- as though the absence of war was the same as peace"
-Dorothy Thompsan
LE for commoner on 06/23/2005 09:21 AM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/23/2005 10:29 AM CDT
use Mod Impact. I can kill faster with my LE than my HE in things far under powered compared to me, but then, I haven't achieved min RT on my HE.. ... then again, my HE is also Severe Slice.. .. ... But there you are.
Now how I remember you
How I would push my fingers through
Your mouth to make those muscles move
That made your voice so smooth and sweet
Now how I remember you
How I would push my fingers through
Your mouth to make those muscles move
That made your voice so smooth and sweet
Re: LE for commoner on 06/23/2005 10:58 AM CDT
Personally, I would say get a jambiya because it is much more versatile than a katar and weighs less.
Yet each man kills the thing he loves,
By each let this be heard,
Some do it with a bitter look,
Some with a flattering word,
The coward does it with a kiss,
The brave man with a Sword.
Oscar Wilde
Yet each man kills the thing he loves,
By each let this be heard,
Some do it with a bitter look,
Some with a flattering word,
The coward does it with a kiss,
The brave man with a Sword.
Oscar Wilde
Re: LE for commoner on 06/23/2005 01:11 PM CDT
Ok, well now people are saying that LE is an untrainable weapon skill. I guess I've missed something but it seams rather easy to train to me. Course, its like 5th on my weapon skill list.
"They have not wanted peace at all; they have wanted to be spared war -- as though the absence of war was the same as peace"
-Dorothy Thompsan
"They have not wanted peace at all; they have wanted to be spared war -- as though the absence of war was the same as peace"
-Dorothy Thompsan
Re: LE for commoner on 06/23/2005 01:43 PM CDT
LE is certainly trainable, especially when you have the strength/agility to use the mod slice or impact katars. The only issue is its power relative to other weapons in that the rt difference is rather miniscule. Early on it's a little harder, but it gets easier.
~~~ The Son of Damaris ~~~
~~~ The Son of Damaris ~~~
Re: LE for commoner on 06/23/2005 04:58 PM CDT
<<Ok, well now people are saying that LE is an untrainable weapon skill. I guess I've missed something but it seams rather easy to train to me. Course, its like 5th on my weapon skill list.>>
LE is possible, however with a commoner I wouldn't really recommend it as you won't really have the skills to use it efficiently. You'll still be able to swing it with a decent rt, but anything that hits with anything will be too heavy and you'll fatigue quickly.
LE is possible, however with a commoner I wouldn't really recommend it as you won't really have the skills to use it efficiently. You'll still be able to swing it with a decent rt, but anything that hits with anything will be too heavy and you'll fatigue quickly.
Re: LE for commoner on 06/24/2005 09:15 AM CDT
>Ok, well now people are saying that LE is an untrainable weapon skill.
Yes, I said that. And yes, I was peeved at the time.
::shrugs::
What disappoints me is that my two primary weapons that I decided, for rp purposes, were LT and LE jabbers. LT was horrible for years, and was ok for a couple of months so now it is downtweaked.
LE jabbers just are lousy now. I don't even bother.
It gets old, I guess. Forgive my Italian temper.
Daerlynn
Yes, I said that. And yes, I was peeved at the time.
::shrugs::
What disappoints me is that my two primary weapons that I decided, for rp purposes, were LT and LE jabbers. LT was horrible for years, and was ok for a couple of months so now it is downtweaked.
LE jabbers just are lousy now. I don't even bother.
It gets old, I guess. Forgive my Italian temper.
Daerlynn
Re: LE for commoner on 06/24/2005 09:53 AM CDT
Don't get me wrong... LE is not the "best" choice in weapons. Forging and RT changes pretty much killed balance in terms of cost/benefit. It has many limitations and early on can be tedious.
But it does get easier and more effective later on, even if not as favorable as other weapon classes.
I'll just continue sitting back and hoping for improvements.
~~~ The Son of Damaris ~~~
But it does get easier and more effective later on, even if not as favorable as other weapon classes.
I'll just continue sitting back and hoping for improvements.
~~~ The Son of Damaris ~~~
Re: LE for commoner on 06/24/2005 12:48 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/25/2005 05:22 PM CDT
>What disappoints me is that my two primary weapons that I decided, for rp purposes, were LT and LE jabbers. LT was >horrible for years, and was ok for a couple of months so now it is downtweaked.
>LE jabbers just are lousy now. I don't even bother.
If you chose them as your primary weapons for RP, great! However, if you're upset now because they are "lousy" and don't use them anymore, it's silly.
I mean, if you trained them for "years that they were horrid" and only now you're upset with them enough to break you characters RP... Then you may have made a worse choice than you think. In many areas.
>LE jabbers just are lousy now. I don't even bother.
If you chose them as your primary weapons for RP, great! However, if you're upset now because they are "lousy" and don't use them anymore, it's silly.
I mean, if you trained them for "years that they were horrid" and only now you're upset with them enough to break you characters RP... Then you may have made a worse choice than you think. In many areas.
Re: LE for commoner on 06/25/2005 05:38 PM CDT
>I mean, if you trained them for "years that they were horrid" and only now you're upset with them enough to break you characters RP... Then you may have made a worse choice than you think. In many areas.
Jabbers in general have sucked since the combat changes. Jab does less damage, thrust has higher penalties, and the only power shot, lunge, leaves you with a huge defensive penalty. Not to mention that the combos are completely backwards from any normal functioning weapon. Her choice in LT has not always been a viable choice, but jabbing LE's were at one time very functional.
Yet each man kills the thing he loves,
By each let this be heard,
Some do it with a bitter look,
Some with a flattering word,
The coward does it with a kiss,
The brave man with a Sword.
Oscar Wilde
Jabbers in general have sucked since the combat changes. Jab does less damage, thrust has higher penalties, and the only power shot, lunge, leaves you with a huge defensive penalty. Not to mention that the combos are completely backwards from any normal functioning weapon. Her choice in LT has not always been a viable choice, but jabbing LE's were at one time very functional.
Yet each man kills the thing he loves,
By each let this be heard,
Some do it with a bitter look,
Some with a flattering word,
The coward does it with a kiss,
The brave man with a Sword.
Oscar Wilde
Re: LE for commoner on 06/25/2005 09:15 PM CDT
I always used a jabber until the changes. I put up my sabre and went and got a scimitar. I can consistently beat people in spars with 50 more weapons and evasion because they use jabbers. (and they don't know not to lunge). If you don't catch a stun with lunge, you're dead in the water. Hunting-wise, you can't use lunge effectively in any multi situation without getting very very hurt.
Other than that, thrust has more of a defensive penalties than before, and jab... well, jab wasn't great before, and it's not great now. I'd like jabbers as a whole to get another look, and actually have a combo that mirrors pikes.
Jab/Thrust/Lunge.
Instead of the current
Lunge/Thrust/Jab.
Using the biggest hitting move (and biggest penalty) in early position without good balance or position is simply a dumb move. The biggest balance gain combination should allow people to work their way up to a decent hitting move.
-Wighten
Other than that, thrust has more of a defensive penalties than before, and jab... well, jab wasn't great before, and it's not great now. I'd like jabbers as a whole to get another look, and actually have a combo that mirrors pikes.
Jab/Thrust/Lunge.
Instead of the current
Lunge/Thrust/Jab.
Using the biggest hitting move (and biggest penalty) in early position without good balance or position is simply a dumb move. The biggest balance gain combination should allow people to work their way up to a decent hitting move.
-Wighten
Re: LE for commoner on 06/25/2005 09:20 PM CDT
>If you chose them as your primary weapons for RP, great! However, if you're upset now because they are "lousy" and don't use them anymore, it's silly.
>I mean, if you trained them for "years that they were horrid" and only now you're upset with them enough to break you characters RP... Then you may have made a worse choice than you think. In many areas.
All I can say, Timbrewolf, is that you therefore do not know me.
Daerlynn
>I mean, if you trained them for "years that they were horrid" and only now you're upset with them enough to break you characters RP... Then you may have made a worse choice than you think. In many areas.
All I can say, Timbrewolf, is that you therefore do not know me.
Daerlynn
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 09:31 AM CDT
Yes, jabbing weapons on the whole got tanked. Le got hit hard because the alternatives don't afford themselves much to good balance and power, only one of the above. As opposed to reasonably balanced, severe slice weapons. I'm still waiting and hoping for improvement.
~~~ The Son of Damaris ~~~
~~~ The Son of Damaris ~~~
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 10:16 AM CDT
I forged a few of these up on request. At a lighter weight the balance is much better.
A falcata is a light edged type weapon.
You are certain that it could do:
low puncture damage
fair slice damage
poor impact damage
You are certain that the falcata is fairly balanced and is poorly suited to gaining extra attack power from your strength.
You are certain that the falcata is fairly sturdy, and is in pristine condition.
The falcata is made with metal.
You are certain that the falcata weighs about 33 stones.
Strife Magdar Bluefletch of M'Riss
www.play.net/dr/info/guilds/barb.asp
and I quote:
Weapon Forging
Anyone can forge a crude weapon, but only barbarians can produce legendary quality weapons sought after by all.
A falcata is a light edged type weapon.
You are certain that it could do:
low puncture damage
fair slice damage
poor impact damage
You are certain that the falcata is fairly balanced and is poorly suited to gaining extra attack power from your strength.
You are certain that the falcata is fairly sturdy, and is in pristine condition.
The falcata is made with metal.
You are certain that the falcata weighs about 33 stones.
Strife Magdar Bluefletch of M'Riss
www.play.net/dr/info/guilds/barb.asp
and I quote:
Weapon Forging
Anyone can forge a crude weapon, but only barbarians can produce legendary quality weapons sought after by all.
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 11:07 AM CDT
For a commoner I would still suggest the jambiya since it has good balance an fair power for an LE and you can also thrust with it.
PS Daerlynn, have you tried a jambiya? I usually go with a feint, slice, chop, feint, lunge, slice and it seems to work pretty well. although it defaults to slicing, it is still a good jabber.
An ivory-hilted jambiya is a light edged type weapon.
You are certain that it could do:
fair puncture damage
fair slice damage
poor impact damage
You are certain that the jambiya is reasonably balanced and is fairly suited to gaining extra attack power from your strength.
You are certain that the ivory-hilted jambiya is fairly sturdy, and is in pristine condition.
The ivory-hilted jambiya is made with metal.
The ivory-hilted jambiya feels pretty light.
You are certain that the ivory-hilted jambiya is worth exactly 400 lirums
Honesty may be the best policy, but it's important to remember that apparently, by elimination, dishonesty is the second-best policy.
-George Carlin
PS Daerlynn, have you tried a jambiya? I usually go with a feint, slice, chop, feint, lunge, slice and it seems to work pretty well. although it defaults to slicing, it is still a good jabber.
An ivory-hilted jambiya is a light edged type weapon.
You are certain that it could do:
fair puncture damage
fair slice damage
poor impact damage
You are certain that the jambiya is reasonably balanced and is fairly suited to gaining extra attack power from your strength.
You are certain that the ivory-hilted jambiya is fairly sturdy, and is in pristine condition.
The ivory-hilted jambiya is made with metal.
The ivory-hilted jambiya feels pretty light.
You are certain that the ivory-hilted jambiya is worth exactly 400 lirums
Honesty may be the best policy, but it's important to remember that apparently, by elimination, dishonesty is the second-best policy.
-George Carlin
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 02:57 PM CDT
>PS Daerlynn, have you tried a jambiya? I usually go with a feint, slice, chop, feint, lunge, slice and it seems to work pretty well. although it defaults to slicing, it is still a good jabber.
I have tried one, but wasnt sure of the combo to use. I will try that!! Thank you.
I do miss using my tago though. Something about that weapon's description appeals to me.
Daerlynn
I have tried one, but wasnt sure of the combo to use. I will try that!! Thank you.
I do miss using my tago though. Something about that weapon's description appeals to me.
Daerlynn
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 05:19 PM CDT
>>I do miss using my tago though. Something about that weapon's description appeals to me.
I've almost completely traded use of my two other LE's (a shriike for jabbing and a kythe for slicing) for a jambiya. Now I either need to find a way to make the ivory-hilt be ruby, or maybe just get it altered to look like the kythe.
As for combos...when in doubt, ATTACK x3 always works.
Killing you softly with his song,
- Stormsinger Shavay
"We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams"
- Arthur O'Shaughnessy
I've almost completely traded use of my two other LE's (a shriike for jabbing and a kythe for slicing) for a jambiya. Now I either need to find a way to make the ivory-hilt be ruby, or maybe just get it altered to look like the kythe.
As for combos...when in doubt, ATTACK x3 always works.
Killing you softly with his song,
- Stormsinger Shavay
"We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams"
- Arthur O'Shaughnessy
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 05:23 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/26/2005 07:10 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/29/2005 10:47 AM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/29/2005 09:41 PM CDT
I'd suggest learning LE by parrying attacks. Work on brawling, sheild, evasion as you do it.
I'd stay away from jabbers as the penalty to def for such attacks wont be offset with offesnse with such low ranks and poor weapons. SLicing weapons seem to do more damage then impact.
The jaymba's arn't bad for a LE, but I belive that shortswords and katars can be forged at low weights for noobs. In the long run I have yet to find a better weapon then a mod slice forged katar, though i never use the old old katars that app something like l/f/p f/r, maybe damaris's kid can correct me on the app.
Halfling,
http://www.beyondgoodevil.org/users/datarealms/
I'd stay away from jabbers as the penalty to def for such attacks wont be offset with offesnse with such low ranks and poor weapons. SLicing weapons seem to do more damage then impact.
The jaymba's arn't bad for a LE, but I belive that shortswords and katars can be forged at low weights for noobs. In the long run I have yet to find a better weapon then a mod slice forged katar, though i never use the old old katars that app something like l/f/p f/r, maybe damaris's kid can correct me on the app.
Halfling,
http://www.beyondgoodevil.org/users/datarealms/
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 09:22 AM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 01:56 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 02:07 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 02:17 PM CDT
<<anyone wana clue me in on where to get a Jambiya?>>
They are found on Shadowbeasts that live below the Zalfung Swamp just outside Haven. If you are in Haven, and I am about, I can get one for you. Otherwise its a tough area for any youngin to get too, your best bet is to ask over the Haven gweth, sometimes there are hunters down there that can pick one up for you as well.
Rehlyn
Ps. dont think they are found on Ratha unless its in a new area I am not familiar with
Some thoughtful soul has marked the surface of the lock with a drawing of several very happy looking stick figures.
A tasia corsair says, "Well I was hoping to wait for a cleric first but if you watch my stuff I'll depart. Thanks."
They are found on Shadowbeasts that live below the Zalfung Swamp just outside Haven. If you are in Haven, and I am about, I can get one for you. Otherwise its a tough area for any youngin to get too, your best bet is to ask over the Haven gweth, sometimes there are hunters down there that can pick one up for you as well.
Rehlyn
Ps. dont think they are found on Ratha unless its in a new area I am not familiar with
Some thoughtful soul has marked the surface of the lock with a drawing of several very happy looking stick figures.
A tasia corsair says, "Well I was hoping to wait for a cleric first but if you watch my stuff I'll depart. Thanks."
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 03:50 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 05:13 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 05:22 PM CDT
The jambaya from Ratha isnt very good. The jambiya from shadowbeasts is a good weapon (for an LE)
Jambaya fair/low/poor/ reason/poor average strength
Jambiya fair/fair/poor reason/fairly fairly sturdy
Honesty may be the best policy, but it's important to remember that apparently, by elimination, dishonesty is the second-best policy.
-George Carlin
Jambaya fair/low/poor/ reason/poor average strength
Jambiya fair/fair/poor reason/fairly fairly sturdy
Honesty may be the best policy, but it's important to remember that apparently, by elimination, dishonesty is the second-best policy.
-George Carlin
Re: LE for commoner on 06/30/2005 05:39 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 07/05/2005 02:20 AM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 07/05/2005 02:22 AM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 07/21/2005 03:15 PM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 07/22/2005 01:58 AM CDT
LE is definitely viable for a commoner. I wouldn't use it as a primary weapon. I started training my commoner as LE primary and quickly discovered that medium edge far, far outpaced its damage--even at vastly lower ranks. I'd rely on another edge as a primary weapon, then swap out your jambiya when you lock the first. Additionally, there's an added benefit of taking forever to kill something: it really gets the defenses going. But, to reiterate, you can train it. My commoner has nearly 150 ranks in LE.
Re: LE for commoner on 07/31/2005 03:21 AM CDT
Re: LE for commoner on 08/01/2005 03:39 PM CDT