>>I think I'm misunderstanding something about this - what is the purpose of posting an APP CAREFUL of critters if we don't also post the stats/skills of the person making the appraisal?

Because hopefully, you modified the "what it teaches to" which gives others an idea of your skill range combined with the appraisal. The idea is not to just edit talk pages.

If you're not editing anything about what the creature teaches to, then an appraisal/skills are not necessary to add and frankly, silly.

---
NaOH+HI