Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/22/2002 04:18 PM CDT
Links-arrows 1
Reply Reply
How many Paladins out there serve a god, and if you do how do you show your service to that god? If you do not, then can you justify yourself as a Paladin?

Now what I expect from the second question is that someone will reply that they are a champion of a cause, but any class can make that claim, does that make them Paladins as well? I'm very curious as to the responses.

In essense, what makes a Paladin a Paladin? Is service to a deity essential? What separates us from other classes without talking to the mechanics of the game?
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/22/2002 04:31 PM CDT
Links-arrows 2
Reply Reply
In my opinion..... being a paladin isn't doing this or that, it's literally a way of life.

Serrin, for example, serves Rutilor. As a servant of Rutilor.. he has taken upon himself that he should live his life in truth, and will never lie. Other than that, he lives his life as purely as possible, and follows what he consdiers to be the Path of Rutilor... Being truthful and honest, and defending those he deems deserving. Serrin feels that he is the judge of who is deserving of that. Serrin observes and respects the "laws of mortals"... but does not really care one way or the other about them, as long as "Justice" is observed. If it is not, he will likely speak up. He also steps in when he sees someone really getting the short end of the stick in any situation. Unless he deems that it's simply not worth his trouble, or the person is undeserving of such defense.

As an example... if Serrin observes someone being stolen from, but the person being stolen from is a known murderer, he will say nothing, even though the theft is technically a violation of provincial law.

As for what part of that makes him a Paladin. I suppose it would be because he is truly devoted to the service of his God, as opposed to simply raising a sword, and saying it's in the name of Rutilor.

Serrin
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/22/2002 04:37 PM CDT
Links-arrows 3
Reply Reply
>As for what part of that makes him a Paladin. I suppose it would be because he is truly devoted to the service of his God, as opposed to simply raising a sword, and saying it's in the name of Rutilor.<

Excellent reply Serrin, I feel like I know alot more about you. I think this is an example of a Paladin that lives the edicts of his god. Thanks for the reply I'm definately interested in the diversities of the Paladins here.
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/22/2002 04:57 PM CDT
Links-arrows 4
Reply Reply
As a few of you know, I am not primarily a paladin- but one of my people is.

A true paladin is a rather curious creature- humble yet proud, a warrior, yet capable of gentleness when it is called for. The paladin's path, as far as I can see it, is not an easy one. But it is well worth exploring.

I would also like to hear what other elder paladins have to say on this subject.

Ryeka
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/22/2002 06:47 PM CDT
Links-arrows 5
Reply Reply
Madigan worships Chadatru and uses the Book of Deeds as his guide. The Book calls for a paladin to have certain traits, integrity, honor, humility, etc..(I suggest everyone read the Book).

Directly, Madigan always seeks to resolve a dispute with the least about of force and the advantage of all parites if possible. Madigan has not nor will he ever lie, as that is a greater sin and breach of faith to him than any other action. Madigan may not always tell you everything or answer your question, but if he utters a word, it is his belief it is true.

Finally, Madigan believes it his duty and reason for being to serve. Simple things such as helping a young hunter get started in Therengia bring as much pleasure to him as leading in battle.

Anyway, I'm sure most of you are familiar with pious ol' Madigan, so I'm sure that bored you above.

James
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 12:27 AM CDT
Links-arrows 6
Reply Reply
Ok, I'll take a stab at this. Hope this doesn't grow TOO long and wordy.

Redarch took up the Path of the Paladin because of the example of a wounded Paladin that stumbled into his dwarven village one day. Even though the Paladin's wounds were near fatal, when an evil critter was accidentally released from an underground chamber, the Paladin left his sickbed to stand tall in defense of the overwhelmed dwarves. In doing so, he suffered additional wounds that killed him.

That is the example that Redarch tries to live up to. Being the one willing to step up and put his life on the line in defense of others who may or may not be able to do so. Redarch is not a "cop", Redarch is not an "arbiter of Justice", Redarch's mission is NOT to "clean up the law breakers". Redarch is a defender. The one who stands at the bridge or the city gate to defend all those behind him who can't stand there themselves.

Redarch follows Chadatru because that "aspect" of Justice (defender of those who can't defend themselves) is what drew him to that God. Redarch honors Chadatru by standing in defense of the land where he is.. citizen of the Realms, not a particular province. He honors the 13 even as he tries to ignore the "negative" aspects of each.. not because he doesn't acknowledge negatives, but rather because he prefers to focus on the positives instead.
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 03:39 AM CDT
Links-arrows 7
Reply Reply
Michael is pretty much closest to Redarch kinda paladin, in overwhelming odds when everyone falling around him Michael will not leave the forefront of the battle, if he fighting at your side you know he not gona leave you standin untill he falls in battle.

If your slain on the hunting fields its probably Michael you gona see comming over the hill to find you, wether he likes you or not he feels its his duty to help those in need, He trys not to judge others just trys to find the positive in people (sometimes he not good at that bit). To Michael it would be dishonerable not to help.

As per Redarch Michael is not a cop, but also likes to be the protector, defender. To him his honour and his guild is everything, Michael is the fella you wanna see in your corner when things get tough.

I hope that helps you see how I (the player of Michael) see's a paladin.

Michael.
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 08:28 AM CDT
Links-arrows 8
Reply Reply
<<How many Paladins out there serve a god, and if you do how do you show your service to that god? If you do not, then can you justify yourself as a Paladin?>>

::Changes hats from GM to PC::: This is a topic that has always fascinated me as a player. I look forward to reading the responses.

~M
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 11:41 AM CDT
Links-arrows 9
Reply Reply
hmm interest Red. I used to protect more. Now i just get revenge and i put myself in a position to get into conflicts with stuff that i dont approve of. Ferry gangs. Blatant theft in front of the bank. Rock troll nuisances. I dont follow any particular god , but i do know they are out there and i do pay homage to them. Sides, every family needs a blacksheep with a halo.

Clyn
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 12:33 PM CDT
Links-arrows 10
Reply Reply
Taghz believes his duty is to defend the lands from the evils that face it. He pays homage to Peri'el since she keeps the world dragon asleep. He also follows the teachings of Shi'kail and believes that S'kra Dragon followers can get along with the 13 god followers. Taghz dislikes the Dzree sect and makes it his life to strengthen himself so he can strike down the evilness of that sect...

Taghz will also help those in need. Though when it comes to theft he will strike down the thief if possible...

Crusader Taghz
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 12:34 PM CDT
Links-arrows 11
Reply Reply
Glory is a follower of the All-god. His history has been posted in a couple of the RP folders, so I won't repeat it here (I think its interesting, but I would not presume to think that others would see it that way, besides, its kind of long!) <G>.

As a fellow follower of the All-god, I am sure that Lennon will probably post about his beliefs and concepts. Glory generally agrees with the way Lennon sees devotion to the All-god, however Glory does not feel the same "intensity" of belief that is apparent in Lennon.

Glory became a Paladin, more because of what he saw in other Paladins (he grew up among Paladins, his parents being caretakers in the guild) rather than because of any strong personal devotion to the All-god. Although he IS diligent in his prayers, tithing, favors, etc - thus his godly devotion is a big part of his life, its just not as intense as what he sees in others. (I hope that makes sense)

Glory's concept of Paladinhood centers around self-sacrifice with "justice" being a strong component of his motivation. He does not really see himself as a "cop" or a "defender" etc, except when those concepts interact with his self-sacrificing motivation.

Glory tends to drop anything and everything to be of service whenever he hears of someone in need. Thus he always goes to glyph when a general call goes out (and used to always go to cast courage when people actually used to ask for it), etc. He will always go to aid deaders, will always leave his hunting or training to drag, get aid, bond, ward, etc. He tries to do everything he can to provide for new members, to answer questions, etc.

I can only hope he has been successful in promoting an example of self-sacrificing service.

Gloryarm
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 12:45 PM CDT
Links-arrows 12
Reply Reply
>I can only hope he has been successful in promoting an example of self-sacrificing service.

He has been- there are at least two clerics who name him in honor, and one young paladin who endeavor to follow his example.

Ryeka and the brood
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 12:45 PM CDT
Links-arrows 13
Reply Reply
>hmm interest Red. I used to protect more. Now i just get revenge and i put myself in a position to get into conflicts with stuff that i dont approve of. Ferry gangs. Blatant theft in front of the bank. Rock troll nuisances. I dont follow any particular god , but i do know they are out there and i do pay homage to them. Sides, every family needs a blacksheep with a halo.<

I've heard alot of Paladins that seem to follow what they believe to be virtuous in the eyes of their god or gods and some of the reason for choosing to follow said deity.

Clynlyn could you tell me based upon your reply above if you as a Paladin still feels your following any particular virtues, and if not then do you still feel yourself to be a Paladin, and if so why?

This is not to point out who is or isn't doing it right, its to point out the diversities within the guild and help others understand what drives us and defines us.

Krymson.
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 12:52 PM CDT
Links-arrows 14
Reply Reply
Also, is there a Paladin out there who serves no god at all?

I'd really like to hear from someone who doesn't believe in the gods at all and why they chose the Paladin guild, what drives them, and to explain how they define themselves as a Paladin.
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 09:29 PM CDT
Links-arrows 15
Reply Reply
<<I've heard alot of Paladins that seem to follow what they believe to be virtuous in the eyes of their god or gods and some of the reason for choosing to follow said deity.

<<Clynlyn could you tell me based upon your reply above if you as a Paladin still feels your following any particular virtues, and if not then do you still feel yourself to be a Paladin, and if so why?

<<This is not to point out who is or isn't doing it right, its to point out the diversities within the guild and help others understand what drives us and defines us.

i dont think i all my virtue's are benign. Nor do i think i am not a paladin. First and foremost there is no real doctrine or set direction of the guild. I believe i am a paladin, I believe what i do is right. I also believe what i do is right , therefore its paladin like. If its been said later its not the right thing to do anymore then I will stop. But I dont shout open pockets, I dont roll into an area asking people to steal from me. I go into high profile areas where people will do things. I just hope they pick me. And use me as a target.

Besides i think my actions speak for my character. The people who know me can vouch for that. And all things said about me good or bad are probably true.

Clyn
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/23/2002 10:39 PM CDT
Links-arrows 16
Reply Reply
>Also, is there a Paladin out there who serves no god at all?

Benzali is one of them. He acknowledges their existance and that they granted gifts to the paladin guild, but questions their motives. He believes that might does not equal right, even with respect to the gods. He does not actively oppose the gods, as he knows that would most certainly lead to an early demise, but will choose not to do something purely because he feels it would help the gods. For example, Benzali would never fight against an invasion inside the temple.

That is, of course, completely independant of him as a paladin. As a paladin he believes he should do anything in his power to help others. However, in doing so, he places more focus on what he believes will actually help the person than on what the person believes. For example, he will not give a new paladin a suit of plate, because he feels the accomplishment of earning your first suit is far more valuable than the protection you get from a suit given to you.

Player of Linras and Benzali
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/26/2002 04:42 PM CDT
Links-arrows 17
Reply Reply
<<As a fellow follower of the All-god, I am sure that Lennon will probably post about his beliefs and concepts. Glory generally agrees with the way Lennon sees devotion to the All-god, however Glory does not feel the same "intensity" of belief that is apparent in Lennon.>>

If we look at the book of the "Origins of the Realms" we find reference to the Void and the One. The One took the Void as a wife and produced the Planes as offspring. Each of these different realms are seperated by time and space (one of them being Elanthia). The Void wept because of the seperation of her children and each of these tears created a different immortal. The One placed within each of these beings a portion of himself. Upon doing so he ceased to exist, as did the "Void" because well the void was filled with beings.

From this Lennon pictures each immortal as inherantly being part of the "One" or All-god. Together these immortals make up the whole of what is the All-god. As such each immortal that Elanthians worship are only one particualr piece or "face" as is commonly explained of this greater being.

As such, Lennon worships each of these faces equally. Each is a portion of a greater whole and each exemplifies different attributes of the All-god.

As Glory stated, Lennon is certain in his belief and intense in the way in which he worships them. For one, he has 1 favor for each of the gods and will get no more until the time comes where he has none left. If upon departing with 1 favor he comes back to the plane of Elanthis he will go secure one more favor for each immortal. If however, the All-god chooses that he walks the starry road, then so be it that is what was meant to be.

Many people ask how if some immortals contradict each other Lennon can worship them all equally. Well, each immortal has its own perception of what is just or right, however, as a unity there seem to be some overarching ideals of right and wrong. Lennon sides with the majority view of the gods, or what he interprets the majority view to be.

He looks at each immortal as being a seperate entity in the same way humans (and to a lesser extent other races ::snicker::) have different "aspects" of their own personality. Chadatru is the god of justice, an overarching theme. While his two aspects Rutilor, the god of truth and a defender of the gods and Boltof, the god of deciet and dishonesty, can bring about justice depending on the context and situation. In esscence he sees each oif the "seperate" immortals in that light. The neutral aspect represents an overarching theme (representing a personality characteristic of the All-god), and the positive and negitive aspect as representing different ways to express the "themes"...

Lennon is and eternal Squire to the All-god. This is the title he has chosen to portray until a time where the All-god deems him worthy of something more. It is Lennon's opinion that this could not happen, until the time comes where the All-god and each of his "faces" can no longer teach him anything about what it is to be a Paladin (which will probably never happen). Lennon is an Advocate of the Immortals justice, as well as Holy Warrior against abominations of the Immortals majority view.

I suppose that will do for now. If anyone has any other questions concerning this feel free to ask. No gurentee I will answer in a timely manner.

--Just a Squire
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/26/2002 04:46 PM CDT
Links-arrows 18
Reply Reply
I'm planning on making Pureblade into a Gorbesh-God Oriented Paladin.

It's part of my diabolical plot to make random references to things 1% of Elanthia will understand.

Already wrote a two page report on what soulstones are in relation to the Albarian beleif system. Once it's cleaned up more I'll be posting it :P
Reply Reply
Re: Duty in a polytheistic society on 07/28/2002 07:04 AM CDT
Links-arrows 19
Reply Reply
The main reason for my curiosity is to understand diversity in the guild. It seems that for the most part most Paladins are in some way tied with the immortals and follow in what they percieve to be that deitys wishes or virtues. Some Paladins however believe in doing what they percieve to be right or to champion a belief or cause or a group of people or province.

I can't say any of these are wrong or right really, only that I think a true passion for something that is shown through the Paladins actions and deeds that helps define the Paladin. I think though that Paladins, much like the Cleric guild or where I think the mage guild should go, should be set into paths. If not then you leave too much up to speculation around what does or does not make the Paladin and allows those whom really do not fit within the guild to defend themselves due to a lack of definition. The "I'm a Paladin because I'm in the Paladin guild" view is one I think we should as a guild be above. I personally would like to be able to say that each of the members within my guild at least know why they joined the guild, what it is the guild stands for, and how they represent the interests of the guild.

A guild without definition or purpose is simply not a guild. I'd say the Paladin guild is one of the toughest to define or want to define from a mechanics point for several reasons. One you don't want to make everyone in the guild the same but yet can't have such a loose environment where a person can lay claim to being a part of the guild without having to share in the same goals of the guilds purpose. Two, because of the textbook Paladins tie to the immortals you can't do too much with this and not step into the boundary of clerics or so many GMs seem to think. Three, Dragonrealms staff have made a very clear direction away from anything dark or evil when it comes to players which again hampers diversity. (Hell just see how many uses of the word evil you can find in anything vs. the number of time good is used. You can find dark vs light imagery sure but that's about as far as it goes)

I think career paths in the guild would be a great thing. But I think it's going to take a GM to put their foot down and define the role of the Paladin to make that happen. Personally I think if the paths were set by deity or immortal and then use those immortals views and traits to allow such things in the paths as an Armorer, Holy Warriors of a particular ethos (Which would allow those to follow dark or light gods), Defender, Diviner (for those more interested in the magic granted Paladins), Warden or Justice entity, etc. etc.

This would create the definition that Paladins are in fact defenders and protectors of the faith where clerics are preachers and teachers of the faith. While this would still upset some whom do not see themselves in any way tied to the immortals I think in such a case then it should be viewed as a roleplay opportunity for someone who has taken no particular path as to how they fit, what has caused them to lose faith, or do they see themselves as fallen from grace. As far as being worried about division within the guild, the guild is still a whole with the purpose of defending, protecting, and representing all of the faiths brought on by the immortals and the people that follow them. It's simply diversity in terms of how that goal is achieved in each of the different paths.
Reply Reply