Exactly my point, Blas.

Dark paladins dont do that...thats called taking a dark aspect as an excuse and thus making a mockery of the gods...which would mean a free for all on whoever's arse would do that

How can you say that you are a follower of Botolf or Huldah, and not follow their "tenents" (for lack of a better word) That's what I don't get... How can you serve a god of dishonesty without being dishonest yourself, and if you do, why would you do that? I think you've already answered this, somewhere, and I'm going to search the archives in a minute (or not, depending on how fast my hot pocket gets done) but it just doesn't make sense! Why follow those we know aren't doing the right things?

And more importantly...
why follow those we know are doing right? That's the cusp of my issue. That and how we know what's right and wrong.