Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/21/2008 09:19 PM CST
Links-arrows 123
Reply Reply
I agree, though I'm fairly certain some, but not all, brawling moves are broken. Grapple and tackle come to mind immediately. However, there are brawling combinations that train extremely well, and still allow you to kill the critter you're brawling with.


What JLo said is pretty much spot on.

- GM Dartenian
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/22/2008 12:23 AM CST
Links-arrows 124
Reply Reply
>>most brawling moves are broken

Yeah. I think their broken-ness is probably also what allows them to teach even if the character fails the check or is stanced attack 0, but it would be nice if they worked and did more. Also: please more non-violent brawling moves.

-- Player of Szrael.
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/22/2008 12:38 AM CST
Links-arrows 125
Reply Reply
This is definitely #1 on my "stuff I'd like to see fixed" list.

And...

>>Also: please more non-violent brawling moves.

Ditto x 100


Denstimar Dustyfoot
Idon Raider - www.idonraiders.com
"Have you not learned great lessons from those who braced themselves against you, and disputed passage with you?" - Walt Whitman
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/22/2008 12:46 AM CST
Links-arrows 126
Reply Reply
Sorry, I should have been more clear. It actually has nothing to do with traning technique. Mord has no problem learning brawling at all. But when I need a pelt to go get a favor with and the bloody wolves keep retreating cause they are scared of my wee little carving knife (more likely its the avenger that scares them). Grapple sure would be handy so they don't run away. I don't want to have to around begging for a pelt when I'm perfectly capable of getting myself, IF I could just get my hands on them. I could swear not long ago I had no problem grappling them, now.... nope, not a fat chance in ....

Now I could try to manipulate them.... oh wait, nope THATs rather broken too, and at the rate they run way instead of attacking other wolves.... well so much for that thought.


Mordibar- your friendly neighborhood tending dummy
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/22/2008 12:54 AM CST
Links-arrows 128
Reply Reply
I knew what you meant, I was just throwing other broken brawling things into the mix.

I thought you could just sleep them, but I guess that might not work if they have to face you for your avenger to attack them.



Dragonrealms Tourney Calendar: http://tourneydr.com

Zeyurn: My presence is godly enough to warp the random number generator into submissive compliance with my whims.
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/22/2008 07:03 PM CST
Links-arrows 129
Reply Reply
I think brawling has gone leaps and bounds in the right direction, but I also 100% agree that moves like shove, tackle, and grapple need a bit of TLC themselves.
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/23/2008 07:21 AM CST
Links-arrows 130
Reply Reply
What are your stats, Mordibar? Brawling gets a lot better as you increase your strength/agility.

- Mazrian

The Flying Company
http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d194/huldahspal/flyingcompany.png
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 11/23/2008 11:44 PM CST
Links-arrows 131
Reply Reply
Trust me on this, the issue here has nothing to do with stats or skill but with the fact that Brawling is flat out broken. I've no problem grappling and pinning small peccaries or swamp trolls or fendryads, and even do well trying to grapple bristle peccs. There is NO WAY I should not be able to grapple or tackle a blood wolf or a marauder, other then because BRAWLING IS BROKEN.

Could I sleep them? Sure, but I shouldn't have to take 15-20 seconds to cast NB, on something I should just be able to pin quickly and easily. That and its beside the point, brawling is busted and would be nice to see it fixed.

So I'm sticking with my original request, please please please give Brawling a bit of love and fix it?


Mordibar- your friendly neighborhood tending dummy
Reply Reply
Re: Can we PLEASE get Brawling fixed? on 12/10/2008 09:20 PM CST
Links-arrows 132
Reply Reply
Can we get any sort of timeline on this, or update on if its even a current project? If its way behind this thing, the other thing, and some other thing that'll take years, thats ok, but.. can we know?

___________________________________________
You throw your juggling pins precisely at Captain Tevel's chest, hitting it with a decent strike that explodes the chest in a shower of blood and splintered ribs.
[Roundtime 1 sec.]
The Captain Tevel is already very dead.
Reply Reply
Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 07:25 AM CST
Links-arrows 133
Reply Reply
Having gone though all the previous posts, it would appear that all the combat aspects (punch/kick/slap so forth) are not working at the moment and that the best way to learn brawling is the non-combat moves (bob/weave/circle). I am currently using this little combo to try and get my brawling moving.

Top:
put circle
waitfor Roundtime
pause
put weave
waitfor Roundtime
pause
put bob
waitfor Roundtime
pause
goto Top

However, it rarely gets above thoughtful. Anyone have any better combos to try and get this thing moving or is brawling just FUBAR at the moment? If it is just busted can a GM maybe give a comment on roughly where it stands on the priority list?
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 07:45 AM CST
Links-arrows 134
Reply Reply
Attack attack attack works nicely for me when I'm actively training or killing with it. I also constantly bob while training shield and have replaced dodge with bob in all my combos, which moves it well enough by itself.


~Thilan
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 07:46 AM CST
Links-arrows 135
Reply Reply
I've been using circle/bob/weave for the last ~215 ranks. A lot of people just bob over and over and over.

Is this a new character? Or a really skilled one? New characters have trouble getting into the brawling "groove," but it picks up pretty nicely after a while.

If it's a newer character, pick up a parry stick to parry with, as you'll learn some brawling from parrying. Pick up brawling weapons to increase damage from actual brawling attacks. And circle/bob/weave whenever you're just training defenses or magic or whatever.

It should get there eventually.

-- Player of Szrael --


Skills Needed for Kaith Partani
Need 286 (500) Empathy.
Have at least 200 in #1 Armor (Light Chain).
Have at least 240 Evasion.
Have at least 160 Shield Usage.
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 08:04 AM CST
Links-arrows 136
Reply Reply
I use goug claw elbow punch slam and still learn great at 700+ of course I'm hunting Elder Dillos so that might account for some of it




Cute verbs and speaking from hiding are excellent ways to catch a lightning bolt in the face regardless of mystical ninja abilities.

-Armifer
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 09:13 AM CST
Links-arrows 137
Reply Reply
I used circle, and now circle/bob for over 400 ranks. Killing stuff with brawl teaches just fine, but I don't want dead critters =)
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 09:14 AM CST
Links-arrows 138
Reply Reply
Other possible combos (the ones I use):

punch/elbow/kick/slice, repeat

gouge/slap/claw/elbow, repeat

I have no problem at all locking brawling with these combos, with very disparate characters.


Denstimar Dustyfoot
Idon Raider - www.idonraiders.com
"Have you not learned great lessons from those who braced themselves against you, and disputed passage with you?" - Walt Whitman
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 12:37 PM CST
Links-arrows 139
Reply Reply

I think the problem is with newer characters, just using non damaging maneuvers at low ranks doesn't yield experience... try damaging attack until you get it a bit higher.
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 01/16/2009 01:02 PM CST
Links-arrows 140
Reply Reply
>>I think the problem is with newer characters, just using non damaging maneuvers at low ranks doesn't yield experience... try damaging attack until you get it a bit higher.

This is definitely true. My new battle empath character is having a horrendous time learning brawling. Definitely use the attack combos if you can.


Denstimar Dustyfoot
Idon Raider - www.idonraiders.com
"Have you not learned great lessons from those who braced themselves against you, and disputed passage with you?" - Walt Whitman
Reply Reply
Brawling gear on 02/16/2009 01:19 PM CST
Links-arrows 141
Reply Reply
I've been looking, well not too hard, for brawling gear is there any shops that sell them?
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling gear on 02/16/2009 01:22 PM CST
Links-arrows 142
Reply Reply
Traders can get brawling gear, and there is another shop- I think either in Rossman's or P5. Someone else will clarify the location of the other.


Sometimes the key to happiness is not assuming it is locked in the first place- Ziggy

A journey of a thousand SMILES begins with a single step- Ziggy
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling gear on 02/16/2009 01:33 PM CST
Links-arrows 143
Reply Reply
Squishing Emporium: http://www.elanthipedia.com/wiki/RanikMap121

Catalog here: http://www.elanthipedia.com/wiki/Urglub%27s_Squishing_Emporium
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling gear on 02/16/2009 03:45 PM CST
Links-arrows 144
Reply Reply
Appritiate it.
Reply Reply
Rakash Brawling on 06/03/2009 03:34 PM CDT
Links-arrows 145
Reply Reply
Can someone help me out with Rakash moonskin brawling? I've been working my googlefu to try and find some combos or even a general list of what moves do what in the grand spectrum of balance vs power. Any fellow Rakash out there able to give me a hand?
Reply Reply
Re: Rakash Brawling on 06/03/2009 04:20 PM CDT
Links-arrows 146
Reply Reply
attack
Reply Reply
Re: Rakash Brawling on 06/04/2009 08:07 AM CDT
Links-arrows 147
Reply Reply
Nothing special. Use standard brawling combo, when in moonskin add 'bite' to the start or end, or both :). When not in moonskin, 'bite' is a grapple manuever meaning you have to have the person in your arms. When not in moonskin, its a melee manuever. Havnt really tested anything beyond that.




Anyone who has lost track of time when using a computer knows the propensity to dream, the urge to make dreams come true and the tendency to miss lunch.
~Tim Berners-Lee
Reply Reply
Re: Rakash Brawling on 06/09/2009 04:36 AM CDT
Links-arrows 148
Reply Reply
Check my sig.




Magic's Death Caraamon Makdasi,
Gor'Tog Barbarian
Hunta Talna Kortok, built by Gor'Togs, for Gor'Togs
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/home.html
Weapon Combo Balance List
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/balance.xls
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 09:47 PM CDT
Links-arrows 149
Reply Reply
Ok guys. Id brawling really meant to be so difficult to learn? I'm hunting at my level in crossing goblins. I have 28 in brawling. I have been in there 45 minutes as of this moment and brawling has got to thoughtful a few times then pulses back to learning. I did this for an hour earlier.

What do I need to do to get brawling moving? I'm a barbarian and it is my secondary weapon of choice. This is my script I run:

#Brawl

put STANCE SET 100 80 0 100

put gouge
pause 5

put slap
pause 4

put circle
pause 5

put bob
pause 5

put weave
pause 5

rawr:
pause 1
put sk brawling
put kick
pause 5

put slice
pause 4

put punch
pause 4

put elbow
pause 4

put slam
pause 4

put skin gob
pause 3

put bund
put search gob
pause 1

put get co co
put get bron co
pause 1

put search hog

goto rawr

When I'm brawling I have a dagger in hand just to make skinning easier. Do I need to be brawling empty handed or something?
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 10:13 PM CDT
Links-arrows 150
Reply Reply
Personally I just spam bob until locked. It works quite well, doesn't take long, and is fairly silly.

Now if you want to KILL something...
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 10:21 PM CDT
Links-arrows 151
Reply Reply
I tried non damaging moves Rahl. Not just bob alone, I did the circle bob weave shuffle forever. Then I read in this particular thread line that at lower levels damaging moves are far superior to dancing moves for brawling.

I just don't understand why a skill needs to be so tedious to train at low levels. I could understand it being a pain near the cap but not on a brand new toon.

I guess I'll try bobbing spam and see what happens.


Thanks.
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 10:27 PM CDT
Links-arrows 152
Reply Reply
I totally wish "Bobbing for Spam" were a real thing. I believe I will go to the store to order the implements necessary to make that happen.
_________________________________
The HeroMachine 3 Alpha is now open for public testing if you want to make a portrait of your character -- http://www.heromachine.com/heromachine-3-lab/
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 10:41 PM CDT
Links-arrows 153
Reply Reply
if you have enough in a regular weapon, you can learn brawling quite easily dancing with critters. I have no problem locking it on any of my family at different levels of skill.


The undead hordes would like to take this moment to remind you that they are quite happy to eat your brains so that you may test new depart.Please consider it.Hugs and kisses, Team Necro.
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 10:50 PM CDT
Links-arrows 154
Reply Reply
Remember that as of now, experience is directly related to damage (with exceptions). The problem is that brawling damage is directly related to two things, stats, and armor/brawling weapons.

Make sure to use the moves that coincide with your good stats (assuming you have any), stay away from grappling of any sort, and if you're still having problems, try to get ahold of a set of brawling gear.

Unfortunately, this is likely to be a problem you'll meet again in two, three hundred ranks. Compared to fighting with a weapon, it comes up short many times.



Magic's Death Caraamon Makdasi,
Gor'Tog Barbarian
Hunta Talna Kortok, built by Gor'Togs, for Gor'Togs
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/home.html
Weapon Combo Balance List
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/balance.xls
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 11:20 PM CDT
Links-arrows 155
Reply Reply
Thanks Raist. My strength is 20 at lvl 7. I think thats good, for goblin hunting anyway. I use elanthipedias brawling info and most of my damaging maneuvers are based off of strength.

I finally got it to concentrating but I really don't know if it's worth the effort. I've been there for nearly 2hrs.


Where can I get cheap brawling gear?
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/04/2009 11:23 PM CDT
Links-arrows 156
Reply Reply
>Where can I get cheap brawling gear?

The only reliable source is a Trader buying from a single shop up in Muspar'i.

Each piece sells at the shop for between one and two gold lirums. Dunno if you consider that cheap.



Magic's Death Caraamon Makdasi,
Gor'Tog Barbarian
Hunta Talna Kortok, built by Gor'Togs, for Gor'Togs
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/home.html
Weapon Combo Balance List
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/balance.xls
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/05/2009 12:21 AM CDT
Links-arrows 157
Reply Reply
Get brass knuckles.

Then just use punch/elbow over and over.

No balance hit and a 2/1 RT.

I usually just circle over and over but when I want to kill something or lock brawling quick i punch/elbow.
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/05/2009 01:56 AM CDT
Links-arrows 158
Reply Reply
Uhh...well when I brawl I have spiked knuckles and an elbow spike...

Combo is gouge, claw, elbow, shove, punch. or gouge, claw, elbow, punch, slam.

Locked me up since I started in rats, and still does me good in leucros. Then again my character is Prydaen, I have claws. Though there are claws to be found somewhere to use as brawling gear, too. Also umm Boar Clan sells some brawling gear if you're willing to make the hike. And I know a few Traders sell brawling gear for a plat a piece, I go to the bazaar tents often and see brawling gear all over the place.

Hope that helps =D
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/05/2009 01:58 AM CDT
Links-arrows 159
Reply Reply
>Though there are claws to be found somewhere to use as brawling gear, too.

Negatory, there is no brawling item sold that boosts claw damage.
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/05/2009 02:20 AM CDT
Links-arrows 160
Reply Reply
Hrm. The combo is good. I use the same one without the circle, bob, or weave at the beginning. I wonder if the dagger in your hand is messing you up. Are you holding that dagger in your right hand? If so, the slice you will try to slice with that dagger instread of your fist, but I wouldn't think it would impact learning all that much. Assuming right handed use, how badly is slicing with a jabber affecting your balance/position? You are also nearing (but have by no means reached) the upper end of wher egoblins will teach you. Buy 30-35 ranks I had moved on to eels with all three of the Barbs I have played. At goblin levels, again, I wouldn't think it would matter as much, but could poor mentals be holding you back? Are you hitting poorly due to excessively low agility perhaps. I'm just sort of brainstorming possible issues here. Feel free to chime in anyone.




~Talo, Prydaen Barbarian~
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/06/2009 04:02 PM CDT
Links-arrows 161
Reply Reply
>>if you have enough in a regular weapon, you can learn brawling quite easily dancing with critters. I have no problem locking it on any of my family at different levels of skill.

This. My top Prime char learns brawling while using her top weapon just fine, and for kicks sometimes will go punch out a few eidilon steeds just for kicks. And my top Plat character has her brawling as very nearly equal to her ME.

Not to mention throwing in a few none-damaging brawling moves gives the added bonus of letting my character 'rest' before going back in to fight.


Sometimes the key to happiness is not assuming it is locked in the first place- Ziggy

A journey of a thousand SMILES begins with a single step- Ziggy
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/07/2009 01:27 PM CDT
Links-arrows 162
Reply Reply
I'm a fan of (BOB * 30) hunt hunt hunt (BOB * 3) ad nauseum, but my brawling skill is still 110 ranks behind my combats.

~player of Gulphphunger
Reply Reply
Re: Brawling EXP/combo on 07/07/2009 05:47 PM CDT
Links-arrows 163
Reply Reply
>(BOB * 30) hunt hunt hunt (BOB * 3)

Mmmmm, there's a 90 second learning timer on hunt, so why three in a row?




Magic's Death Caraamon Makdasi,
Gor'Tog Barbarian
Hunta Talna Kortok, built by Gor'Togs, for Gor'Togs
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/home.html
Weapon Combo Balance List
http://www.angelfire.com/rpg2/caraamon/balance.xls
Reply Reply