Since the GM's have been so open about formulas and stuff lately, might we get a list of the difficulty of materials to enchant? I know it's been stated that mithril was the easiest magic metal to enchant, but what about the rest and various types of magical wood?
-Richard/Fjalar.
Material difficulty on 04/10/2015 05:57 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 08:17 AM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 10:50 AM CDT
Below is a list of materials for weapons, shields, armor, bows, and runestaves, and their relative difficulty. The smaller the number, the more difficult it is to enchant. While some materials exist in many categories, their difficulty may be different (e.g. it's pretty difficult to enchant a wooden sword vs. a wooden runestaff).
GameMaster Estild
Weapons | |
Material | Difficulty |
adamantine | -500 |
alexandrite | -500 |
black-alloy | 0 |
bone | -250 |
bronze | -50 |
copper | -50 |
coraesine | -999 |
drakar | -50 |
drake | 0 |
eahnor | 15 |
eonake | -60 |
faenor | 15 |
feras | 0 |
glaes | -10 |
glass | 0 |
golvern | -10 |
gornar | -50 |
imflass | -30 |
invar | 0 |
iron | -30 |
kelyn | 0 |
krodera | -999 |
kroderine | -999 |
mein | -10 |
mithglin | 15 |
mithril | 20 |
modwir | 0 |
obsidian | -500 |
ora | 0 |
ora-black | -75 |
ora-white | -40 |
razern | -20 |
rhimar | -50 |
rolaren | -40 |
ruby | -500 |
steel | -10 |
urglaes | -999 |
urnon | -999 |
vaalorn | 10 |
veil-iron | -50 |
vultite | 0 |
wood | -100 |
zelnorn | -999 |
zorchar | -50 |
Shields | |
Material | Difficulty |
adamantine | -500 |
black-alloy | 0 |
bronze | -50 |
carmiln | 10 |
copper | -50 |
deringo | -20 |
drakar | -50 |
eahnor | 15 |
faewood | 0 |
fireleaf | 15 |
glaes | -10 |
glowbark | -10 |
golvern | -10 |
gornar | -50 |
hoarbeam | 5 |
illthorn | 0 |
imflass | -30 |
invar | 0 |
iron | -30 |
ironwood | 0 |
kakore | 0 |
kroderine | -999 |
mein | -10 |
mesille | 0 |
mithglin | 15 |
mithril | 20 |
mossbark | 0 |
ora | 0 |
orase | 0 |
rhimar | -50 |
rolaren | -40 |
steel | -10 |
urglaes | -999 |
vaalorn | 10 |
veil-iron | -50 |
villswood | 0 |
vultite | 0 |
white-alloy | 0 |
wood | -10 |
zelnorn | -999 |
zorchar | -50 |
Armor | |
Material | Difficulty |
adamantine | -500 |
black-alloy | 0 |
bone | -250 |
bronze | -50 |
cloth | 0 |
copper | -50 |
drakar | -50 |
eahnor | 15 |
glaes | -10 |
golvern | -10 |
gornar | -50 |
imflass | -30 |
invar | 0 |
iron | -30 |
kroderine | -999 |
leather | -10 |
mein | -10 |
mithglin | 15 |
mithril | 20 |
ora | 0 |
rhimar | -50 |
rolaren | -40 |
steel | -10 |
urglaes | -999 |
vaalorn | 10 |
veil-iron | -50 |
vultite | 0 |
white-alloy | 0 |
wood | -100 |
zelnorn | -999 |
zorchar | -50 |
Bows | |
Material | Difficulty |
carmiln | 10 |
deringo | -20 |
glowbark | -10 |
hoarbeam | 5 |
ipantor | -40 |
mesille | 0 |
mossbark | 0 |
ruic | -60 |
sephwir | -25 |
villswood | 0 |
wood | -10 |
wyrwood | -60 |
yew | -20 |
Runestaves | |
Material | Difficulty |
carmiln | 10 |
deringo | -20 |
faewood | 0 |
fireleaf | 15 |
glowbark | -10 |
hoarbeam | 5 |
illthorn | 0 |
ironwood | 0 |
kakore | 0 |
lor | -25 |
mesille | 0 |
mossbark | 0 |
orase | 0 |
rowan | 20 |
villswood | 0 |
witchwood | -75 |
wood | -10 |
GameMaster Estild
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 10:52 AM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 11:12 AM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 12:24 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 12:40 PM CDT
Reformatted, column-wise:
Well, it looks right in my spreadsheet... <grumble>
DIF | FIC | ULT | IES | |||
Material | Weapons | Shields | Armor | Bows | RuneStaves | |
adamantine | -500 | -500 | -500 | |||
alexandrite | -500 | 0 | ||||
black-alloy | 0 | -50 | 0 | |||
bronze | -50 | -50 | ||||
copper | -50 | -50 | ||||
coraesine | -999 | |||||
drakar | -50 | -50 | -50 | |||
drake | 0 | |||||
eahnor | 15 | 15 | 15 | |||
eonake | -60 | |||||
faenor | 15 | |||||
feras | 0 | |||||
glaes | -10 | -10 | -10 | |||
golvern | -10 | -10 | -10 | |||
gornar | -50 | -50 | -50 | |||
imflass | -30 | -30 | -30 | |||
invar | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
iron | -30 | -30 | -30 | |||
kelyn | 0 | |||||
krodera | -999 | |||||
kroderine | -999 | -999 | -999 | |||
mein | -10 | -10 | -10 | |||
mithglin | 15 | 15 | 15 | |||
mithril | 20 | 20 | 20 | |||
obsidian | -500 | |||||
ora | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
ora-black | -75 | |||||
ora-white | -40 | |||||
orase | 0 | |||||
razern | -20 | |||||
rhimar | -50 | -50 | -50 | |||
rolaren | -40 | -40 | -40 | |||
ruby | -500 | |||||
steel | -10 | -10 | -10 | |||
urglaes | -999 | -999 | -999 | |||
urnon | -999 | |||||
vaalorn | 10 | 10 | 10 | |||
veil-iron | -50 | -50 | -50 | |||
vultite | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
white-alloy | 0 | 0 | ||||
zelnorn | -999 | -999 | -999 | |||
zorchar | -50 | -50 | -50 | |||
bone | -250 | 10 | -250 | |||
glass | 0 | |||||
cloth | 0 | |||||
leather | -10 | |||||
wood | -100 | -10 | -100 | -10 | -10 | |
carmiln | 10 | 10 | ||||
deringo | -20 | -20 | -20 | |||
faewood | 10 | 0 | ||||
fireleaf | 15 | 15 | ||||
glowbark | -10 | -10 | -10 | |||
hoarbeam | 5 | 5 | 5 | |||
illthorn | 0 | 0 | ||||
ipantor | -40 | |||||
ironwood | 0 | 0 | ||||
kakore | 0 | 0 | ||||
lor | -25 | |||||
mesille | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
modwir | 0 | |||||
mossbark | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
orase | 0 | 0 | ||||
rowan | 20 | |||||
ruic | -60 | |||||
sephwir | -25 | |||||
villswood | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
witchwood | -75 | |||||
wyrwood | -60 | |||||
yew | -20 |
Well, it looks right in my spreadsheet... <grumble>
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 01:38 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 02:44 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 02:54 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 03:50 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 07:14 PM CDT
I was always under the impression that holy, flaring and weighted weapons could not be enchanted further. Has that changed? I see feras and razern and eonake on the weapon charts.
"So, what does that green line on the graph represent?"
"Oh, that's the projection of a hypothetical offspring from a union between Sauron and Cruella de Ville; we use that as a baseline for determining character alignment."
"So, what does that green line on the graph represent?"
"Oh, that's the projection of a hypothetical offspring from a union between Sauron and Cruella de Ville; we use that as a baseline for determining character alignment."
Re: Material difficulty on 04/11/2015 07:21 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 04/12/2015 11:23 AM CDT
>>I was always under the impression that holy, flaring and weighted weapons could not be enchanted further. Has that changed? I see feras and razern and eonake on the weapon charts.
Weapons of a holy nature can be enchanted with the aid of Eoveneh potions which are made through the alchemy system.
Weapons of a holy nature can be enchanted with the aid of Eoveneh potions which are made through the alchemy system.
Re: Material difficulty on 04/12/2015 03:56 PM CDT
>> And my personal favorite! Stone. . . -999?
It definitely isn't -999 (I've had too many successes for that to the case) but I was wondering about this myself (given my multi-year stone dagger enchanting project). If I had to guess I would say stone is either -100 or -250.
Also wondering about Eonake shields (if not listed no penalty?). I've completed one Eonake shield to 7x and have another in the pipe.
-- Faulkil
"Wyrom isn't interacting with me, I think he is AFK scripting."
It definitely isn't -999 (I've had too many successes for that to the case) but I was wondering about this myself (given my multi-year stone dagger enchanting project). If I had to guess I would say stone is either -100 or -250.
Also wondering about Eonake shields (if not listed no penalty?). I've completed one Eonake shield to 7x and have another in the pipe.
-- Faulkil
"Wyrom isn't interacting with me, I think he is AFK scripting."
Re: Material difficulty on 04/16/2015 02:43 PM CDT
Re: Material difficulty on 01/12/2016 02:49 PM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 01/12/2016 03:08 PM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 01/12/2016 03:23 PM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 01/21/2016 11:25 AM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 01/21/2016 11:39 AM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 03/08/2016 11:47 PM CST
This list was previously posted, but it does not include veniom. Where do armor and weapons made of veniom fall?
Below is a list of materials for weapons, shields, armor, bows, and runestaves, and their relative difficulty. The smaller the number, the more difficult it is to enchant. While some materials exist in many categories, their difficulty may be different (e.g. it's pretty difficult to enchant a wooden sword vs. a wooden runestaff).
GameMaster Estild
Below is a list of materials for weapons, shields, armor, bows, and runestaves, and their relative difficulty. The smaller the number, the more difficult it is to enchant. While some materials exist in many categories, their difficulty may be different (e.g. it's pretty difficult to enchant a wooden sword vs. a wooden runestaff).
Weapons | |
Material | Difficulty |
adamantine | -500 |
alexandrite | -500 |
black-alloy | 0 |
bone | -250 |
bronze | -50 |
copper | -50 |
coraesine | -999 |
drakar | -50 |
drake | 0 |
eahnor | 15 |
eonake | -60 |
faenor | 15 |
feras | 0 |
glaes | -10 |
glass | 0 |
golvern | -10 |
gornar | -50 |
imflass | -30 |
invar | 0 |
iron | -30 |
kelyn | 0 |
krodera | -999 |
kroderine | -999 |
mein | -10 |
mithglin | 15 |
mithril | 20 |
modwir | 0 |
obsidian | -500 |
ora | 0 |
ora-black | -75 |
ora-white | -40 |
razern | -20 |
rhimar | -50 |
rolaren | -40 |
ruby | -500 |
steel | -10 |
urglaes | -999 |
urnon | -999 |
vaalorn | 10 |
veil-iron | -50 |
vultite | 0 |
wood | -100 |
zelnorn | -999 |
zorchar | -50 |
Shields | |
Material | Difficulty |
adamantine | -500 |
black-alloy | 0 |
bronze | -50 |
carmiln | 10 |
copper | -50 |
deringo | -20 |
drakar | -50 |
eahnor | 15 |
faewood | 0 |
fireleaf | 15 |
glaes | -10 |
glowbark | -10 |
golvern | -10 |
gornar | -50 |
hoarbeam | 5 |
illthorn | 0 |
imflass | -30 |
invar | 0 |
iron | -30 |
ironwood | 0 |
kakore | 0 |
kroderine | -999 |
mein | -10 |
mesille | 0 |
mithglin | 15 |
mithril | 20 |
mossbark | 0 |
ora | 0 |
orase | 0 |
rhimar | -50 |
rolaren | -40 |
steel | -10 |
urglaes | -999 |
vaalorn | 10 |
veil-iron | -50 |
villswood | 0 |
vultite | 0 |
white-alloy | 0 |
wood | -10 |
zelnorn | -999 |
zorchar | -50 |
Armor | |
Material | Difficulty |
adamantine | -500 |
black-alloy | 0 |
bone | -250 |
bronze | -50 |
cloth | 0 |
copper | -50 |
drakar | -50 |
eahnor | 15 |
glaes | -10 |
golvern | -10 |
gornar | -50 |
imflass | -30 |
invar | 0 |
iron | -30 |
kroderine | -999 |
leather | -10 |
mein | -10 |
mithglin | 15 |
mithril | 20 |
ora | 0 |
rhimar | -50 |
rolaren | -40 |
steel | -10 |
urglaes | -999 |
vaalorn | 10 |
veil-iron | -50 |
vultite | 0 |
white-alloy | 0 |
wood | -100 |
zelnorn | -999 |
zorchar | -50 |
Bows | |
Material | Difficulty |
carmiln | 10 |
deringo | -20 |
glowbark | -10 |
hoarbeam | 5 |
ipantor | -40 |
mesille | 0 |
mossbark | 0 |
ruic | -60 |
sephwir | -25 |
villswood | 0 |
wood | -10 |
wyrwood | -60 |
yew | -20 |
Runestaves | |
Material | Difficulty |
carmiln | 10 |
deringo | -20 |
faewood | 0 |
fireleaf | 15 |
glowbark | -10 |
hoarbeam | 5 |
illthorn | 0 |
ironwood | 0 |
kakore | 0 |
lor | -25 |
mesille | 0 |
mossbark | 0 |
orase | 0 |
rowan | 20 |
villswood | 0 |
witchwood | -75 |
wood | -10 |
GameMaster Estild
Re: Material difficulty on 03/09/2016 07:25 AM CST
>This list was previously posted, but it does not include veniom. Where do armor and weapons made of veniom fall?
To my knowledge, veniom cannot be made into weapons or armor as the base material (or it shouldn't be!). Admittedly, I am no forging master so I guess it is used as an adornment on weapons and armor to make them lighter, or weightless.
~Contemplar~
To my knowledge, veniom cannot be made into weapons or armor as the base material (or it shouldn't be!). Admittedly, I am no forging master so I guess it is used as an adornment on weapons and armor to make them lighter, or weightless.
~Contemplar~
Re: Material difficulty on 03/09/2016 02:14 PM CST
>This list was previously posted, but it does not include veniom. Where do armor and weapons made of veniom fall? |
To my knowledge, veniom cannot be made into weapons or armor as the base material (or it shouldn't be!). Admittedly, I am no forging master so I guess it is used as an adornment on weapons and armor to make them lighter, or weightless. |
~Contemplar~ |
http://www.play.net/gs4/info/armory/materials.asp#Veniom
"Type: Weapon, Armor"
Veniom has always been a strange material, some places like alter 9 say it's so thin and light it crumbles easily, other places say it's a true metal which contradicts alter 9. I believe Wyrom said he would be updating alter 9 to no longer mention the crumbling easily part, because it makes no sense.
There are sets of armor out there that inspect as veniom, they're very old and exceedingly rare. I know that it has been enchanted, because they were base 4x and I've seen them in 5x and 6x versions. I assume the material difficult is 0, but I was hoping to confirm. I hope I don't regret my request and this somehow turns into a stealth nerf of -999 difficulty. Even though nothing stated about the material says it would be more difficult, or impossible to enchant.
Re: Material difficulty on 03/09/2016 03:12 PM CST
>>There are sets of armor out there that inspect as veniom, they're very old and exceedingly rare. I know that it has been enchanted, because they were base 4x and I've seen them in 5x and 6x versions. I assume the material difficult is 0, but I was hoping to confirm. I hope I don't regret my request and this somehow turns into a stealth nerf of -999 difficulty. Even though nothing stated about the material says it would be more difficult, or impossible to enchant.
If I had to guess from the 5 successful ensorcells I did on a set of veniom armor I'd guess -40. It seemed comparably difficult to the rolaren ensorcells I did of the same enchant.
Re: Material difficulty on 03/10/2016 10:30 AM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 03/10/2016 01:14 PM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 03/10/2016 01:42 PM CST
Re: Material difficulty on 09/26/2017 09:23 PM CDT