Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 11:24 AM CST
Links-arrows 1
Reply Reply
A great many Warrior Mages allready take on apprentinces, as do members of other guilds, without a code requirement that they do so. In my experience, such requirements are the best way to have an even worse-off newbie population. Power-circlers, sunday gamers, and people with the maturity level of a four-month-old iguana do the absolut minimum for the code to recognize this status and then virtually abandon the student.

Eventually you get into 'slave' apprentinces created for the purpose of leveling a mage who needs on, and other issues. People with the time, energy, and knowledge to make good teachers get fed up with the system and abandon it after a taking a couple of students who now expect their master to ignore them once the base requirements are met.

It just rarely works, I haven't seen it work yet. Even in really serious MU* environments you run into huge problems with people who can't make time commitments.

-Robert
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 11:34 AM CST
Links-arrows 2
Reply Reply
I've seen war mage with apprentices. I sat and watched one talk to her "apprentice" for hours once in front of the guild. The way she talked down to him was embarassing. It seemed to be a relationship based on the older mage's self importance. I won't even call her an elder, cause she wasn't even close. I don't think it was a good way to demonstrate to the younger mage how to act to people of lower level.

To be fair I've seens other mage take on apprentices and actually be helpful.

Watching that one gal turned my stomach.

I think you have a great idea, one thats been tossed around a number of times before. Just be careful, for some its merely an ego-trip.

Miabelle


There is nothing more liberating than dancing barefoot.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 11:43 AM CST
Links-arrows 3
Reply Reply
Blech.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 06:05 PM CST
Links-arrows 4
Reply Reply
Dont want to be an apprentice...dont want to have an apprentice...sometimes I would love to kill some of the apprentices walking around...and sometimes I wish I could kill some of the "masters".

That being said, I have no problem with an apprentice system being created as a mechanic as perhaps a new technique to learn teaching/scholarship...I DO have a problem with anything that would make an apprenticeship program mandatory on either side (master or apprentice) for advancement. If someone wants to roleplay as having an apprentice or being one, I am happy they make that choice...Don't put me into that role cause if I get an apprentice I'll probably end up instituting a permanent thump clause in our relationship.

Skazar

Gnomes are too short to have apprentices...
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 06:06 PM CST
Links-arrows 5
Reply Reply
>>Watching that one gal turned my stomach.

We need names.

-Frogspawn



Dragonrealms: It's like a cult, only more expensive.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 06:19 PM CST
Links-arrows 6
Reply Reply
<<We need names.

-Frogspawn
>>

Thanks for the reminder...If someone told me I had to be Frogspawn's apprentice to advance in the warrior mages guild I'd walk myself and become a barbarian...that would be a lot less painful than what she would dish out for insubordination.


Skazar
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 06:40 PM CST
Links-arrows 7
Reply Reply
<<Now my argument: When I was young, I had a REALLY hard time figuring things out, and for that, feel as if I am not what I could be, skill wise.>>

I'll fully agree with that as well, when I was young I didn't know anything, and it's taken me forever to figure out what I have, and I sure still don't know everything. But isn't that part of the fun of the game?, If I was just handed all the answers, DR would loose alot of it's luster to me, I play because there are challenges and things to figure out.

Beliel
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 10:11 PM CST
Links-arrows 8
Reply Reply
Which is exactly why we would have a committee of sorts, to keep the mentors in line, to make sure that the apprentices were not abused, and that the elders were not abusing their superiority
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/10/2003 10:33 PM CST
Links-arrows 9
Reply Reply
we have the mentors society in the crossing that can help any youngun with a question they may have. most of the mages that are old enough and wise enough to actually take on an apprentice dont even live in the crossing where the young mages would need them.


Deloria.....Rissan War Witch
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 12:13 AM CST
Links-arrows 10
Reply Reply
>>Which is exactly why we would have a committee of sorts, to keep the mentors in line, to make sure that the apprentices were not abused, and that the elders were not abusing their superiority

Why exactly do I need to be forced to take on an apprentice then have a committee to keep me in line?

For the love of god: If you want an apprentice, get an apprentice; if you want a mentor, find a mentor.

If you want to force other people to have apprentices, go start some kind of elaborate cult and sacrifice a goat to Thor.

-Frogspawn



Dragonrealms: It's like a cult, only more expensive.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 08:22 AM CST
Links-arrows 11
Reply Reply
Ok, lemme reword this a bit -- this is an idea proposed to help younger mages learn their place in the realms, in our guild, it would not be a guild requirement, it would be a recommendation. Please remember all, this is an open discussion, feedback is a good thing, there have been many ideas taken into consideration, such as raising the age of the teacher to 25, as at that age, they are no longer wet behind the ears. We would like to make it official so that rewards could be given to the teacher for their time, and for their knowledge. This is just a think tank idea right now, however, we are starting a petition of those interested, signing the peition does not mean that you would enroll in teh program, it means that you would be willing to support it and discuss it further. and again, I stress, it would not be a requirement, but in order to recieve the rewards, you would need to be enrolled in the program.
Overview: Cirle 20-25 :: no more than 2 apprentices under circle 10 :: teaching, scholarship and time rewards :: Benefitting the younger generation as well as bringing honor to the guild. a mage can be a master at 40th, apprenticeship begins before 10th, lasts untill 25 or test, at 15 apprentice becomes journeyperson, after 20 apprentice can take a test to prove him or herself." And all would be overseen by a committee.
-Zalinyar
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 09:27 AM CST
Links-arrows 12
Reply Reply
From the newbies point of view I am sure it would be a really sweet deal. That is until I took them to say Theren and... somehow... some way... they got lost. :)

I guess I am just saying if I wanted to be all bout the RP I would have been a bard. Don't force me to be a magic slinging bard! :) I don't think you realize how exahausting hunting in goblins for 2 hours can be when your over 50th. Its a good idea, but if it did get implemented I think it should be of those two peoples free will, and not a guild wide change.

Good brainstormin though!
Amhed Amosh.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 10:12 AM CST
Links-arrows 13
Reply Reply
<<We would like to make it official so that rewards could be given to the teacher for their time, and for their knowledge. This is just a think tank idea right now, however, we are starting a petition ... >>

Two questions. First, who is "we" and second, why take voluntary actions of human kindness and introduce a bureaucracy? You know, virtue is its own reward and all that? The reward for mentoring a novice is gaining a new friend, I'd rather have that than a gold star for my forehead given by some governing board.

Gizella
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 10:27 AM CST
Links-arrows 14
Reply Reply
sorry my fiance drug me over here and i have to say this....

i dont see what she is proposing to be a guild req to circle at all what i think she is asking is a reward to the parties involved and for the parties involved alone like par say if so-and-so takes time to teach whats-there-name then and a verb to link there teaching or something so each gets a small bonous to pulses or something.

just my two coppers on behalf of my fiance cause as im a barb i cant teach her a darn thing about finger waving.


Aj
"Deadly force is that force which a person uses with the purpose of causing or which he/she should know would cause a substancial risk of death or suriuos bodily harm"
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 10:51 AM CST
Links-arrows 15
Reply Reply
Ok, first answer "We" is myself and a few others, listed on our petition of intrest, which "We" intend to present to Gauthus. Second answer -- to give our guild a more diverse unity than it has ever seen before. We all know the history of our guild is somewhat shaded, and the elders passing along their knowledge would present a new outlook for new warmies. True, the reward for mentoring, gaining a new friend is unlike anyother, and as long as the mentor does not abuse his/her strenght, ie. getting a big head, and is willing to commit to self sacrifice, and is not doing it for any reason other than passing on their knowledge, what would be wrong with setting up a reward system, encouraging it? Even self gratification deserves a little recognition. If it works well for our guild, it could be possibly encorperated to realm wide. People who get more gratification from the game from the start -- let's say "Joe Schmuckernelly" takes a trial run in DR. after the month is up he quits, because he was "dazed and confused" because he had no idea what he was supposed to do. If he had a personal mentor, he would have known, fell in love with the realms,(like the rest of us here) and subscribed. Ie- making SIMU more money, allowing them to pay the gm's more, or hire more gm's, which inturn allows us more benefits in the long run. Everyone wins.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 11:53 AM CST
Links-arrows 16
Reply Reply
My only real beef with the proposal as submitted is -- the requirement to have an apprentice to reach X circle. An apprentice shouldn't be something forced onto people. I'm sure there are quite a few people content with just minding their own business and being that solitary mage. I'm not out to force everyone to be social :).

That being said, Apprenticeship on the whole is a neat idea. The thing that could really be further brainstormed on is -- what benefits could apprenticeship have? I mean, its really easy to create a nominal apprenticeship system and just let people RP out how they want to do it. I think it'd be cool if some more benefits could be thought up of. Something to really hammer home the student -> teacher aspect of the system :).


Valdrik
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 12:19 PM CST
Links-arrows 17
Reply Reply
<<I think it'd be cool if some more benefits could be thought up of. Something to really hammer home the student -> teacher aspect of the system

Chores. Apprentices need lots of chores to do. Give each master a really really dirty tower/fortress with self-messing dishes, self-dirtying floors and other menial tasks to have his apprentice slave over while he sips a cool beverage and targets hummingbirds from the comfort of his hammock under the shade tree.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 09:05 PM CST
Links-arrows 18
Reply Reply
As usual Gizella articulated eloquently my feelings on this matter.

It seems to me that when you give an award for a nice/kind act you run the risk of cheapening the motives of the giver. Did the person apprentice ye for kindness sake or for a reward?

The only reward that I can come up with would be a title denoting your activity. In the case of apprenticing someone perhaps Teacher of the Arcane as a title.

Please keep any reward Rp in nature.

I salute anyone who takes the time to orientate a new comer.

Rys
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/11/2003 11:09 PM CST
Links-arrows 19
Reply Reply
>>That being said, Apprenticeship on the whole is a neat idea. The thing that could really be further brainstormed on is -- what benefits could apprenticeship have? I mean, its really easy to create a nominal apprenticeship system and just let people RP out how they want to do it. I think it'd be cool if some more benefits could be thought up of. Something to really hammer home the student -> teacher aspect of the system :).

Well, there's always the obvious one:

Give the system-acknowledged Master/Apprentice pair a bonus to Teaching (Master)/Scholarship (Apprentice) when the Master is teaching a skill to his apprentice.

The main problem with anything like this is making sure that any bonus is not abused. It is not very expensive for someone with a steady income to have a secondary, basic, account to hold a "slave" apprentice (or series of apprentices) on.

~Kyn
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/12/2003 12:42 AM CST
Links-arrows 20
Reply Reply
I will make my apprentices do my laundry, then take them to fire sprites to show them the uber mana, and then log off and leave them stranded and bleeding internally.

Except for the gnome apprentices: the gnome apprentices I will put in a burlap sack and throw into the Selgotha.

-Frogspawn



Dragonrealms: It's like a cult, only more expensive.
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/12/2003 04:53 PM CST
Links-arrows 21
Reply Reply
<<Except for the gnome apprentices: the gnome apprentices I will put in a burlap sack and throw into the Selgotha.

-Frogspawn
>>

Like I said before...I'd rather become a barbarian than be Frogspawns apprentice...I just dont look right in burlap.


Skazar
Reply Reply
Re: War Mage Apprenticeship on 03/13/2003 10:16 AM CST
Links-arrows 22
Reply Reply
hmmmmm . .. .Since when was Merlin allowed in our realms? Seriously, the teacher would give a suggested training program that the student would follow, obviously the training worked for the elder, why wouldn't it work for the younger.
Reply Reply